TELEVISION
This Is Your News Cracked: The Bloviator Keith Olbermann and the Blowhard from 'Nicetown'
I USED TO BE AMUSED BY KEITH OLBERMANN, MSNBC's bully pulpit. I was dazzled by his eloquence and taken in by the
righteousness he wore on his sleeve. I was an early fan in the late 90s during his first go-round at MSNBC, captivated by his wit and his daily lacerations on the Monica Lewinsky scandal. And though I did not always agree with him, he was nevertheless the only must-see TV for me. Yet there were moments when the righteous mask slipped from his face and I saw glimpses of the carnival barker, and I suspected his real intentions: to sell more tickets.
Then, for various reasons I turned off the TV, put it in storage. And when I pulled it out again, Olbermann's big head and bellowing voice seemed to literally crash through the screen. I had been debriefed, and for the first time I was annoyed that cable news was first and foremost entertainment. I relished even more the real-time, honest conversations of C-Span.
Chris Matthews was always there in the background, feeding fodder for this political junkie-lite. And though he was a hometown boy from the not-so-nice neighborhood of
"Nicetown," Matthews'
analyses never seemed especially acute. Calling his show "Hardball'' seemed like the title an indulgent parent would give a coddled child's pitches. And watching it was like eating at a Greek restaurant because you loved Greek food, not because the chow was good.
Then Hillary Clinton ran for president. And all at once
MSNBC became
apparent for what it is: a frat house filled with women-haters. And since they were the cool kids in the media, who frequently threw parties and invited the less popular boys (Jonathan Alter,
Howard Fineman, I'm talking about you) soon all the boys were trying to impress the alpha newshounds with their barks at Clinton. Crabby was flabberghasted when a media favorite Alter called for Hillary to
get out of the race. That was back in March, before Hillary won Texas, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Kentucky, and despite Alter's claim to be "dreaming of a brokered convention for decades." Liar.
Now MSNBC's shrillness has gotten so ear-piercing that journalists with bona fides are speaking up.
News patrician Tom Brokaw
had to correct Olbermann's claim that Clinton had "shoehorned" news coverage for herself. "Well, I think that's unfair," the elder-statesman said. "I don't think sheshoehorned her way in. When you look at the states that she won and the popular vote that she piled up, and the number of delegates that she has on her side, she's got real bargaining power in all of this."
As far as I know Olbermann did not make Brokaw one of his "Worst" persons in the world! Yet dare I say Olbermann proves her point when he anoints Katie Couric with that title after she
criticized pundits who have "crossed the line" with their sexist slants against Hillary.
Time magazine claims the
bloviator has blown his "last remaining gasket. "Every time he turns up the volume to 11 like this lately, he sounds like just another of the cable gasbags he used to be a corrective to,'' said James Poniewozik. Crabby couldn't say it any better.
But, surprise, surprise,
guess who just beat Bill O'Reilly in the ratings? And the American Journalism Review wonders aloud if Olbermann is the
"future of journalism." I'm not amused anymore by cable news. I'm frightened. Brokaw's gone, Couric's on the decline and Time is getting thinner.
And now we know why Olbermann's become the anti-corrective: the screaming sells. The carnival barker steps forth.